Fire at Cleveland Metal Recycler Highlights Hot Work and Process Safety Dangers
Cleveland, OH - A significant fire occurred at a Cleveland-area metal recycling facility, causing substantial damage and emitting a large plume of smoke over the city. A second fire was reported at the same facility days later. While the specific details of the incident are still under investigation, it serves as a critical reminder of the inherent risks in the recycling industry, particularly concerning hot work and the unexpected presence of hazardous materials.
The facility is a scrap metal recycling plant, which typically receives, sorts, and processes various types of metal from different sources. This can include anything from old vehicles and appliances to industrial scrap. The process often involves cutting, shredding, and melting metals, activities that carry significant fire and explosion risks.
What Could Have Caused the Fire?
Fires at metal recycling plants are not uncommon. Several factors, alone or in combination, could lead to such an event:
Hot Work: Activities like cutting metal with torches or grinders are a primary and frequent source of ignition. Sparks from these operations can easily ignite flammable materials present in the scrap yard, such as residual fuels, oils, plastics, and even combustible metal dust. If proper hot work procedures were not followed, a stray spark could have easily started the blaze.
Presence of Ammunition/Explosives: It is not unusual for live ammunition or other explosive materials to be inadvertently included in scrap metal. If a live round were to be sheared, crushed, or exposed to high heat, it could detonate, potentially igniting surrounding combustible materials.
How Industry Standards Could Have Addressed the Hazard
This incident highlights the importance of robust safety management systems. Specifically, two OSHA standards are highly relevant: the standard for Welding, Cutting, and Brazing (commonly known as the "Hot Work" standard) and the Process Safety Management (PSM) of Highly Hazardous Chemicals standard.
Hot Work Requirements (29 CFR 1910.252)
OSHA’s regulations for hot work are designed to prevent fires by controlling ignition sources. Key requirements include:
Hot Work Permits: Before any cutting, welding, or other spark-producing work begins in an area where flammable materials are present, a permit should be issued. This process ensures a formal review of the hazards and necessary precautions.
Fire Watch: A trained fire watch is required to be present during and for at least 30 minutes after hot work is completed. Their sole duty is to watch for and extinguish any fires that may start.
Clearance of Combustibles: The area around the hot work should be cleared of all flammable and combustible materials for a radius of at least 35 feet. If materials cannot be moved, they must be protected with fire-resistant guards or blankets.
If the fire was initiated by hot work, adherence to these requirements would have significantly reduced the likelihood of the incident.
Process Safety Management (29 CFR 1910.119)
While a metal recycling facility is not typically a facility that would fall under OSHA's PSM standard, the standard could be applicable depending on the materials being processed. Specifically, disassembling explosives, like bullets, could be covered.
PSM applies to processes involving specific threshold quantities of highly hazardous chemicals, including explosives. If a recycling facility were to knowingly or unknowingly accept and process large quantities of materials containing explosives (such as military scrap or large caches of ammunition), it could potentially be subject to PSM requirements.
Under PSM, the facility would be required to:
Conduct a Process Hazard Analysis (PHA): This is a systematic evaluation of a process to identify potential hazards and recommend controls. A PHA would identify the risk of ammunition detonating during processing and would require the implementation of safeguards to prevent it.
Develop Written Operating Procedures: This would include procedures for safely identifying and handling scrap that may contain explosive materials.
Train Employees: Workers would need to be trained on the specific hazards of the materials they are handling and the procedures for safely managing them.
By applying the principles of PSM, even informally, a facility can better anticipate and control the unique hazards of its operations.
Sources:
OSHA 1910.252 - General requirements for Welding, Cutting, and Brazing
OSHA 1910.119 - Process safety management of highly hazardous chemicals.
Fire at Cleveland Waste Paper Recycling - inquiry launched | The Northern Echo
https://fox8.com/news/industrial-fire-causes-heavy-smoke-in-cleveland/
Below is a video that shows a fire reigniting at a Cleveland recycling plant, which is similar to the incident described. Fire reignites at Cleveland Recycling Plant